Peyton Manning, not Tom Brady, is actually the GOAT, according to PFR’s Hall of Fame monitor metric

One of the main narratives following Super Bowl LV was Tom Brady’s undisputed claim as the NFL‘s GOAT. Even all-world receiver Jerry Rice conceded that title to Brady, who won his seventh Super Bowl and fifth Super Bowl MVP at age 43. While Brady’s status as the GOAT can still be debated, his longevity and sustained excellence is truly peerless. 

That being said, Brady is not the GOAT when it comes to a Pro Football Reference metric. The website created a “Hall of Fame Monitor” in 2019 that was designed to estimate a player’s chances at being inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Using approximate value, Pro Bowls, All-Pros, championships and other statistical milestones, the site created a point system to determine the pecking order at each position. 

At quarterback, Peyton Manning holds the top spot with 258 points. Brady is No. 2 with 250.94 points, followed by Brett Favre (178.84 points), Aaron Rodgers (163.72 points), Johnny Unitas (169.34 points), Joe Montana (153.45 points), Drew Brees (140.5 points), John Elway (137.78 points), Fran Tarkenton (117.28 points), and Dan Marino (116.85 points). While Brady has five more rings than Manning, Manning’s two titles, five MVP awards (compared to Brady’s three) and seven All-Pro selections (compared to three for Brady) gives him a slight edge for the time being. But while Manning’s career is about to be immortalized in Canton, Ohio, Brady can add to his point tally in the coming seasons. 

Philip Rivers, who announced his retirement following the Colts‘ playoff loss to Buffalo, is actually 12th on Pro Football’s QB Hall of Fame metric with 97.64 points. He’s just behind Steve Young (112.98 points) and ahead of Barr Starr (97.53 points), Matt Ryan (97.43 points), and Ben Roethlisberger. (95.38 points). 

Eli Manning, in case you were wondering, is 21st on the list with 83.41 points. While his point tally is well short of the Hall of Fame average, Manning’s ranking is higher than Hall of Famers Joe Namath (82.5 points), Bob Griese (73.45 points), Troy Aikman (64.85 points), and Jim Kelly (59.1 points), among others. He also has more points than current Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson (74.2 points). 

While Brady can still catch Manning, Rice’s place atop the wide receiver food chain is pretty secure. Rice’s 311.81 points are more than twice as many as the second-ranked receiver, Randy Moss (149.59 points). While Moss’ 23 touchdown catches in 2007 remains a single-season record, Rice’s three rings, 10 All-Pro selections (compared to four for Moss) and 13 Pro Bowls (Moss was a six-time Pro Bowler) put him in a class by himself. 

Here’s a look at the top-five players at each position, according to Pro Football Reference’s Hall of Fame Monitor. We’ll also include current players who are close to the average point total for Hall of Famers at their position. 


Peyton Manning — 258 points

Tom Brady — 250.94 points 

Brett Favre — 178.84 points 

Aaron Rodgers — 163.72 points 

Johnny Unitas — 160.34 points 

Average point tally for HOF quarterbacks: 104 

Notable current players: Matt Ryan (97.43 points), Ben Roethlisberger (95.38 points), Russell Wilson (74.20 points) 


Walter Payton — 214.91 points 

Jim Brown — 182.41 points 

Barry Sanders — 178.05 points 

Emmitt Smith — 176.30 points 

LaDainian Tomlinson — 136.15 points 

Average point total for HOF running backs: 107

Notable current players: Adrian Peterson (123.85 points), Frank Gore (100.05 points), LeSean McCoy (83.14 points) 

Interesting nugget: Brown led the NFL in rushing for eight of his nine seasons. His 1,863-yard season in 1963 was the most ever at that time. 


Jerry Rice — 311.81 points 

Randy Moss — 149.59 points 

Marvin Harrison — 147.60 points 

Larry Fitzgerald — 140.92 points

Terrell Owens — 139.83 points 

Average point total for HOF wide receivers: 105 

Notable current players: Fitzgerald, Julio Jones (100.82 points), Antonio Brown (98.7 points)

Interesting nugget: In just 12 games, Rice caught 22 touchdown passes in 1987, which stood at the single-season record until Moss caught 23 touchdowns in 2007. 


Tony Gonzalez — 196.33 points 

Antonio Gates — 113.63 points 

Shannon Sharpe — 113.23 points 

Dave Casper — 111.62 points 

Jason Witten — 105.62 points 

Average point total for HOF tight ends: 98 

Notable current players: Rob Gronkowski (89.51 points), Travis Kelce (73.16 points) 

Interesting nugget: Of the top-five tight ends on this list, only Sharpe and Casper played on Super Bowl-winning teams. Sharpe won back-to-back titles with the Broncos; Casper caught a touchdown pass in the Raiders‘ win over Minnesota in Super Bowl XI. 


Bruce Matthews — 158.7 points 

John Hannah — 153.1 points 

Randall McDaniel — 148.75 points 

Alan Faneca — 134.23 points 

Larry Little — 133.73 points 

Average point total for HOF guards: 110 

Notable current players: Zack Martin (67.78 points), David DeCastro (44.33 points), Mike Iupati (37.43 points) 

Interesting nugget: Five of Matthews’ 14 Pro Bowl selections came at center, as Matthews temporarily switched positions midway through his career. 

Offensive tackle 

Anthony Munoz — 160.65 points 

Forrest Gregg — 139.5 points 

Jim Parker — 121.25 points 

Ron Yary — 120.18 points 

Willie Roaf — 117.3 points 

Average point total for HOF offensive tackle: 101 

Notable current players: Jason Peters (89.7 points), Tyron Smith (73 points), Andrew Whitworth (59.65 points) 

Interesting nugget: Gregg, a key member of the Packers‘ 1960s dynasty, actually coached Munoz in Cincinnati from 1980-83. The duo helped the Bengals reach their first Super Bowl in 1981. 


Dermontti Dawson — 128.23 points 

Jim Otto — 124.78 points 

Mike Webster — 117.6 points 

Dwight Stephenson — 111.95 points 

Kevin Mawae — 99.05 points 

Average point total for HOF centers: 109 

Notable current players: **Maurkice Pouncey (73.78 points), Alex Mack (64.58 points), Jason Kelce (51.28 points)

** — Pouncey retired following the 2020 season 

Interesting nugget: Dawson succeeded Webster in Pittsburgh following Webster’s departure for Kansas City in 1989. For a 25-year span, the Steelers had a top-five all-time center manning their offensive line.  

Defensive tackle 

Bob Lilly — 159.2 points 

Alan Page — 157.1 points 

Randy White — 142.18 points 

Joe Greene — 136.53 points 

John Randle — 135.6 points 

Average point total for HOF defensive tackles: 114 points 

Notable current players: Aaron Donald (127.63 points), Ndamukong Suh (79.98 points), Geno Atkins (75.85 points), Fletcher Cox (71.98 points) 

Interesting nugget: Page became the first defensive player to win league MVP in 1971. While he never won league MVP, Greene succeeded Page as Defensive Player of the Year in 1972. He won the honor for a second time in 1974, while also winning the first of four Super Bowls over a six-year span. 

Defensive end 

Reggie White — 237.75 points 

Bruce Smith — 211.35 points 

Jack Youngblood — 124.15 points 

J.J. Watt — 123.88 points 

Michael Strahan — 123.6 points 

Average point total for HOF defensive ends: 103 

Notable current players: Watt, Calais Campbell (77.58 points), Cameron Jordan (69.1 points), Chandler Jones (62.63 points) 

Interesting nugget: The NFL’s first big free agent signee, White helped deliver Green Bay’s first title in 29 years with his three-sack effort in the Packers’ win over the Patriots in Super Bowl XXXI. 

Inside linebacker 

Ray Lewis — 197.03 points 

Mike Singletary — 171 points 

Jack Lambert — 151.65 points 

Dick Butkus — 128.85 points 

Luke Kuechly — 118.4 points 

Average point total for HOF inside linebackers: 114 

Notable current players: Bobby Wagner (96.68 points), K.J. Wright (35.4 points), Sean Lee (26.5 points)

Interesting nugget: Butkus and Kuechly were not penalized for having relatively short careers. Butkus retired after nine seasons and 119 career games. Kuechly played eight seasons and in 118 regular season games before retiring after the 2019 season. 

Outside linebacker 

Lawrence Taylor — 215.68 points 

Derrick Brooks — 162.8 points 

Jack Ham — 143.7 points 

Ted Hendricks — 137.35 points 

Junior Seau — 119.58 points 

Average point total for outside linebackers: 106 

Notable current players: Khalil Mack (83.35 points), Lavonte David (42.45 points), Justin Houston (39.25 points) 

Interesting nugget: Taylor joined Page as the NFL’s only defensive league MVPs in 1986. He led the NFL with 20.5 sacks that season while also leading the Giants to their first Super Bowl title. 

Defensive back

Rod Woodson — 118.05 points

Deion Sanders — 174.43 points 

Ronnie Lott — 173.75 points 

Ed Reed — 150.4 points 

Willie Wood — 130.73 points 

Average point total for Hall of Fame defensive backs: 106

Notable current players: Richard Sherman (79.38 points), Patrick Peterson (78.95 points), Chris Harris Jr. (60.1 points), Stephon Gilmore (57.65 points), Tyrann Mathieu (54.5 points) 

Interesting nugget: In 1995, Woodson made NFL history by becoming the first professional athlete to return from reconstructive knee surgery in the same season. Woodson played in Super Bowl XXX after suffering a torn ACL in Week 1. 


Morten Anderson — 97.45 points 

Adam Vinatieri — 92.7 points 

Gary Anderson — 65.9 points 

Nick Lowery — 57.63 points 

Jan Stenerud — 56.53 points 

Average point total for Hall of Fame kickers: 77 

Notable curent players: Justin Tucker (45.9 points), Stephen Gostkowski (44.13 points), Robbie Gould (22.58 points) 

Interesting nugget: While Vinatieri’s two game-winning field goals are part of NFL lore, Morten Anderson’s game-winning overtime field goal in the 1998 NFC Championship Game gave the Falcons an improbable win over the Vikings and Gary Anderson, who missed a critical 38-yard field goal earlier in the game. 


Shane Lechler — 63.68 points 

Ray Guy — 52.33 points 

Sean Landeta — 47.23 points 

Don Chandler — 37.45 points 

Johnny Hekker — 30.08 points 

Average point total for Hall of Fame Punters: 52

Notable current players: Hekker, Andy Lee (23.5 points), Dustin Colquitt (16.85 points) 

Interesting nugget: The first punter inducted in Canton, Guy was selected to seven Pro Bowls during his time with the Raiders. He was the starting punter on each of the Raiders’ three Super Bowl championship teams. 

Source link

Related Articles

Back to top button